Will Creation & Estate Planning: In a Will, Even the Smallest Word Can Decide the Outcome
Ashish Shah, Wealth Tech Multipliers, Ahmedabad - 9825268868
In a Will, even the smallest word can decide the outcome
Sometimes a person writing a Will names a gift only in broad terms, such as "a car" or "a diamond ring". Indian law treats a broad description very differently from a precise one.
The core point is this: when the description is general, the executor may have to arrange or purchase the item for the beneficiary, even if the person who made the Will did not own that item when he or she passed away.
It is easiest to understand through two situations.
(A) The word "my" is not used - a general gift
Suppose a Will says, "I give a car to B". This is a general description. Whether the person actually owned a car or not makes no difference.
Here the executor must provide something that fairly matches the description. If the estate has enough money or assets, the executor has to buy a car and hand it over to B.
The same reasoning applies to "a diamond necklace" or "a pair of carriage-horses". The executor must arrange such items, as long as the estate can afford them.
The rule: a general gift must be fulfilled by the executor, by purchasing the item if needed.
(B) The word "my" is used - a specific gift
Now take the wording, "I give my residential flat to B". The word "my" changes the position greatly. It points to one particular item that the person owns.
If, at the time of death, the person no longer owns that item, the bequest fails completely. The executor is not bound to buy anything.
For example, if a Will says "my gold necklace" or "my shop" but the person did not own it when he or she passed away, the beneficiary cannot ask the executor to go and buy the necklace or the shop. The gift simply does not take effect.
The rule: a specific gift using "my" depends on that exact item existing in the estate. If it does not, the bequest fails.
Conclusion
- Without "my" (general gift): the executor must arrange or buy the item.
- With "my" (specific gift): only that exact item passes; if it is not there, nothing is given.
So a single word in a Will can change the result entirely. This is why a Will must be drafted with great care, so that the true wish of the person making it is carried out.
Legal reference: Section 171, Indian Succession Act, 1925.
Disclaimer: This article is for general education only and is not legal advice. Please consult a qualified advocate for your situation.
Ashish Shah, Wealth Tech Multipliers, Ahmedabad - 9825268868
#Will #EstatePlanning #WealthTechMultipliers
Comments
Post a Comment